fermenter vs mixing tank

Fermenter vs Mixing Tank: What are the Differences?

Fermentation is a process that involves the growth of microorganisms, such as bacteria, yeast, or fungi, in a liquid medium to produce various products, such as biopharmaceuticals, food and food additives, chemicals, and biofuels. Fermentation can be carried out in different types of vessels, such as shake flasks, cell culture dishes, T-flasks, bioreactors, or fermenters.

In this article, we will compare and contrast two common types of fermentation vessels: fermenter and mixing tank. We will explain what they are, how they work, what are their advantages and disadvantages, and what are their applications.

fermenter
mixing tank

What is a Fermenter?

A fermenter is a specialized vessel that is designed to provide optimal conditions for the growth and metabolism of microorganisms. A fermenter can sometimes also be called a bioreactor or a fermentation tank. There are fermenters used in the alcohol industry and fermenters used in the more advanced biotechnology industry. The fermenters used for brewing beer or alcohol are usually much simpler than the biotechnology fermenters. Here in this article, the word fermenter is used to refer to the biotechnology fermenter. A fermenter typically has the following features:

  • It is made of sterile and corrosion-resistant materials, such as glass, plastic, or stainless steel.
  • It has a stirring system that provides adequate aeration and agitation for uniform mixing of the culture medium and the microorganisms.
  • It has sensors and probes that monitor and control various parameters, such as temperature, pH, dissolved oxygen, pressure, foam level, etc.
  • It has ports and valves that allow the addition or removal of culture medium, microorganisms, nutrients, inhibitors, products, etc.
  • It has a cooling system that removes excess heat generated by the microbial metabolism.

A fermenter can vary in size and shape depending on the scale and purpose of the fermentation process. A fermenter can range from a few milliliters to thousands of liters in volume. A fermenter can have different configurations, such as batch, fed-batch, or continuous mode.

What is a Mixing Tank?

A mixing tank is a general term for any vessel that is used to mix fluids or solids. A mixing tank can also be called a mixer or a blender. A mixing tank typically has the following features:

  • It is made of durable and easy-to-clean materials, such as metal or plastic.
  • It has an impeller or a propeller that provides mechanical energy for fluid motion and mixing.
  • It may have baffles or other devices that enhance the mixing efficiency and prevent vortex formation.
  • It may have heating or cooling coils that adjust the temperature of the contents.

A mixing tank can vary in size and shape depending on the type and amount of materials to be mixed. A mixing tank can range from a few liters to several cubic meters in volume. A mixing tank can have different configurations, such as single-phase or multiphase mixing.

What are the Differences between Fermenter and Mixing Tank?

The main differences between fermenter and mixing tank are:

  • A fermenter is specifically designed for microbial cultivation, while a mixing tank is used for general mixing purposes.
  • A fermenter usually requires sterile conditions and precise control of environmental parameters, while a mixing tank ususally does not.
  • A fermenter usually has more complex components and functions than a mixing tank.
  • A fermenter consumes more power than a mixing tank due to the need for aeration and agitation.

What are the Advantages and Disadvantages of Fermenter and Mixing Tank?

The advantages and disadvantages of fermenter and mixing tank are:

Fermenter

Advantages:

  • It allows high productivity and quality of microbial products due to optimal growth conditions.
  • It enables scale-up and technology transfer of fermentation processes due to standardized design and operation.
  • It facilitates research and development of new fermentation processes due to versatile functionality.

Disadvantages:

  • It is more expensive and difficult to maintain than a mixing tank due to higher requirements for sterility and control.
  • It poses higher risks of contamination and failure than a mixing tank due to more complex components and functions.
  • It generates more waste heat than a mixing tank due to higher metabolic activity.

Mixing Tank

Advantages:

  • It is cheaper and easier to maintain than a fermenter due to lower requirements for sterility and control.
  • It is more flexible and adaptable than a fermenter due to simpler design and operation.
  • It consumes less power than a fermenter due to lower mechanical energy input.

Disadvantages:

  • It provides lower productivity and quality of microbial products than a fermenter due to suboptimal growth conditions.
  • It limits scale-up and technology transfer of fermentation processes due to non-standardized design and operation.
  • It hinders research and development of new fermentation processes due to limited functionality.

What are the Applications of Fermenter and Mixing Tank?

The applications of fermenter and mixing tank are:

Fermenter

Fermenters are widely used in various industries that involve microbial production of valuable products, such as:

  • Biopharmaceuticals: Fermenters are used to produce recombinant proteins, vaccines, antibodies, hormones, enzymes, etc. using genetically modified microorganisms.
  • Food and food additives: Fermenters are used to produce fermented foods, such as cheese, yogurt, bread, beer, wine, etc. using natural or selected microorganisms. However, these types of fermenters are not the fermenters we discussed in this article.
  • Chemicals: Fermenters are used to produce organic acids, alcohols, amino acids, vitamins, etc. using microbial fermentation of sugars or other substrates.
  • Biofuels: Fermenters are used to produce bioethanol, biobutanol, biodiesel, biogas, etc. using microbial fermentation of biomass or waste materials.

Mixing Tank

Mixing tanks are widely used in various industries that involve mixing of fluids or solids, such as:

  • Chemicals: Mixing tanks are used to mix reactants, solvents, catalysts, etc. for chemical synthesis or separation processes.
  • Pharmaceuticals: Mixing tanks are used to mix active ingredients, excipients, solvents, etc. for drug formulation or delivery processes.
  • Cosmetics: Mixing tanks are used to mix oils, waxes, fragrances, colors, etc. for cosmetic production or packaging processes.
  • Food and beverages: Mixing tanks are used to mix ingredients, flavors, preservatives, etc. for food and beverage processing or packaging processes.

Conclusion

Fermenter and mixing tank are two common types of vessels that are used for different purposes in various industries. A fermenter is a specialized vessel that provides optimal conditions for microbial cultivation and product formation. A mixing tank is a general vessel that provides mechanical energy for fluid motion and mixing. They have different features, advantages, disadvantages, and applications. Understanding their differences can help you choose the right vessel for your fermentation or mixing needs.

Contact us for your equipment need. With industrial-leading short lead time and quick delivery, we can help you jump-start your project.